
This is the Undisputed Ranking of the 2024 Girl Scout Cookies
🔺 Each year between January and April, the Girl Scouts offer cookies for sale
🔺 The best-selling variety of all-time is Thin Mints
🔺 2025 is the last time Toast-Yay! and Girl Scout S'mores cookies will be available
Each year at this time I’m tasked with an assignment that takes a full weekend.
I’m responsible for acquiring samples of each Girl Scout cookie package.
Under the watchful eyes of Franklin and Rocky (my Girl Scout cookie-loving, four-legged sidekicks), I sample each and compile my official ratings.
This year, I bought my samples from a troop outside Shoprite in Absecon and the Shoprite at English Creek.
We made our purchasing while undercover, in order to preserve the integrity of our mission.
It was a difficult assignment, but I do my best work under pressure.
Here is How This Year's New Jersey Girl Scout Cookies Ranked:
New Jersey Girl Scout Cookies Rank Worst to First
Gallery Credit: Steve McKay/Townsquare Media
Fascinating facts you may not know about Girl Scout Cookies.
🍪 Girl Scout cookies weren't always so fancy. They were originally just sugar cookies. The Girl Scouts even published their recipes in the newspaper.
🍪 Thin Mints are the best-selling Girl Scout cookie. They make up 25% of all cookie sales.
🍪 Today, all Girl Scout cookies are made at one of two licensed bakeries. Little Brownie Bakers and ABC Bakers.
🍪 Sales of Girl Scout cookies stay local. The money helps fund local council activities.
🍪 Girl Scouts sell over 200 million boxes of cookies annually.
🍪 The Girl Scouts have been selling cookies since 1917 (108 years)
🍪 Girl Scout cookie season is generally late January through March.
🍪 This year, a box of Girl Scout cookies cost six dollars.
🍪 2025 will be the last time you'll be able to purchase Toast-Yay! and Girl Scout S'mores cookies.