This Longtime NJ Pizza Chain Just Shut Down After 40 Years—Who’s Next?

Another day, another chain restaurant with its lights off and the parking lot empty. In New Jersey and beyond, it’s starting to feel like this is happening more and more.

It’s Not Just You. Chains Are Having a Hard Time

There’s a bunch of stuff hitting them all at once. First, everything costs more now: ingredients, packaging, rent, you name it. On top of that, hiring good staff has been super tough. Some spots can’t find enough people to cook, clean, or keep the doors open seven days a week. You’ve probably seen restaurants cutting their hours or closing early to keep up.

And honestly, people aren’t as into the big chains as they used to be. There’s this shift happening. Instead of sitting at the same old place with the same old menu, people in Jersey are looking for cool mom-and-pop spots or fun new local restaurants that feel more personal. Chains just don’t give off that “special” vibe anymore.

READ MORE: These 5 NJ Towns Could Be The First To Get a Buc-ee's

Closures Are Starting to Pile Up

It’s not just a couple of places here and there. Some well-known names are calling it quits on NJ altogether. Whether it’s Caribbean-inspired spots like Bahama Breeze or old-school sit-down chains, a lot of them have quietly packed it up. And more could be on the way if things don’t turn around.

So, What’s the Plan?

Some chains try to keep up by offering more delivery, takeout deals, or digital loyalty programs. Others are tweaking their menus to feel more “local” or focusing on smaller spaces that cost less to run. But still, none of that really matters if people aren’t excited to eat there anymore.

Honestly? It’s a weird time for restaurants in general, but especially for the ones that used to be everywhere. New Jersey’s food scene is changing fast, and the chains that can’t adapt might not make it.

YOU'LL ALSO LIKE: Beloved Island-Themed Chain Restaurant Closes All But One Location in NJ

I was born and raised in Toms River, and even though there have always been many choices for excellent Italian food, when I was a kid, we would stop at a Pizza Hut every now and then. It was an inexpensive option for parents on a budget. Many community events were also held at Pizza Hut on Route 37 in Toms River.

Social media was abuzz with rumors that the Hut in TR had suddenly shut down. Google lists the once-pizza giant as "temporarily closed." I stopped by my old stomping grounds to see what was happening. I was greeted with this sign in the window.

Some had speculated that the ancient building was being remodelled. A view from the parking lot could suggest that it is true.

Contractors on the ground confirmed that Pizza Hut on Route 37 is indeed no more. All that's left are the memories of birthday parties, greasy fingers, and the salad bar.